READ NO FURTHER, PIANO JAZZ LOVERS

Every few years I give piano jazz another chance. I have friends whose cheerleading for this vile branch of popular music is relentless, and the feeling that I'm missing out on something slowly builds and needs release every so often by the application of a brutal dose of reality. So I listened to an hour or so on the radio this morning--really, really early this morning, since the station's programmers have the good sense not to cause the majority of its listeners to vow angrily to withhold their contribution from next year's fundraiser. Piano jazz reminds me of nothing so much as the doodling I used to do on the margins of my pad during interminable, boring meetings at work (no aspersion intended at any particular workplace; I could have worked at a Lap Dance Training Center, and once the hour milestone was reached in any given meeting, I would begin lazily obliterating any notes I had taken with little cubes and starbursts and scathing caricatures of the higher-ups.) Beginning, often, with a hoary old standard, the pianist slowly becomes bored and lapses into indolent filigrees, notes tumbling out like a cascade of Chiclets, full of C dim7 and A sus4, signifying nothing. There is no discernible passion to it, to my ears. When I want piano jazz, I'll travel back to Professor Longhair, and revel in his raucous outbursts of energy. So now my pipes are cleaned, my prejudices are comfortably replenished, and I can relax for another few years.




Reader Comments (6)
don't get me started on this topic
It's not really fair to single out the piano players for shooting. I've often heard similar crimes from trumpet, sax, clarinet, and skat purveyors. Bunch of wankers. Thelonius I have a soft spot for, though. He was the real deal.
Your drawing stands toe to toe with Daumier.
Your drawing stands toe to toe with Daumier.
The godlike genius of Bill Evans. I rest my case.
Having another chance, what those piano players do? I think piano has one shortcoming compare to phones. Piano cannot have sound that is equivalent to the breathing of phone players.
Every once in a while, I feel irritating for not be able to have long tone like trumpets, trombone, or other reed instruments.